Hey Nick, thanks for sticking with me. I added a dkim key for lgechurch.email like you said. That all went fine. The only thing I wasn't sure of was what domain to use in the Key Table for lgechurch.email, so it looks like:

Should it be more like:


My original Key Table script entry for renncoautomation.us is:


My Signing Table script entries for both looks like:


Then I have two dkim TXT entries in my Clear Center DNS records. One for 202002._domainkey.renncoautomation.us and the other for 202003._domainkey.renncoautomation.us, the latter since lgechurch.email is merely a virtual website on my ClearOS server, not my primary Clear Center domain of renncoautomation.us. Clear Center will only allow you to choose the domains hosted by them when configuring your DNS records. The data is the generated key in the 202002.txt and 202003.txt files respectively. I entered these same dkim TXT records in my Google Domain, using 202002._domainkey.renncoautomation.us and 202003._domainkey.renncoautomation.us respectively, for the names of the TXT records.

Looking at you and your church's DNS set up, You won't receive e-mails back as they will end up at Google as they are set up as your primary mail servers.

I had forgotten during all my experimenting that I had used Google's servers in my Clear Center MX records for renncoautomation.us. I removed those and added server.renncoautomation.us instead. Then I tested that by using Kopano to send an email to check-auth@verifier.port25.com. I received a reply promptly. Nothing stood out to me in the email body as being a problem.

I then tried sending another email from the church Joomla site and it still got thrown in the spam folder in my gmail. I feel like I'm getting closer. I wish I could talk to Google on the phone or at the least, send their support team an email and get some specific guidance. I am hosting two domains for our church with them. Here's the header of the latest spammed email: